Student Engagement

Fostering Student Engagement When It’s Low

Middle and high school teachers can try sparking engagement by focusing on students’ connections to each other and their work.

November 19, 2026

Your content has been saved!

Go to My Saved Content.
monkeybusinessimages / iStock

As a colleague of mine reminds me, “Teaching is heart work.” We do it for the connections with the kids, we do it to foster their deeper appreciation for what it means to be human, and we do it to help them become engaged, active citizens in their community and world.

But let’s be real: Not all days feel like this.

When engagement is low, I turn to three instructional strategies: fostering discourse among students and their connections with each other, using poetry to build students as writers, and making learning relevant.

Strategy 1: Connection and Discourse

When kids are dragging their feet and have their heads down, my first move is to reconnect with them and create spaces for them to reconnect with each other.

As a teacher, I do this work because I love high school kids and I want to hear what they have to say about the world. When kids are dragging, I try to create spaces for them to talk, to share, to express their unique opinions, and to reconnect with each other.

Maybe you’re rolling your eyes. “When kids are least engaged, you want them to magically engage in a discussion?” Yes. Because I know they will. When students are given a discussion-worthy text—one that has enough controversy to spark various opinions—they will have a lot to say. In English language arts class, I often pair a nonfiction text with a fictional book unit and then turn the class over to the students to discuss it. I tend to use a simple text response graphic organizer to help kids wrestle with major themes of the text and make sure they are prepared to engage in the discussion.

After kids have read the text and prepared for the discussion, I let them talk. Whether you have students in small table group discussions or bigger Socratic seminars or fishbowl groups, let kids talk and engage with each other. I assign students to be facilitators and, as much as possible, try not to speak. Using the app TeachFX gives me great data on student voice during these discussions. There are so many great resources for encouraging student discourse and teaching academic discussion.

Strategy 2: Poetry

I know what you are thinking: “Poetry? Most kids hate poetry. When they are struggling with engagement, you want more poetry?”

Yes! I want to create opportunities for students to reflect on what it means to be human, to build connections with each other, and to write their own poetry. I am talking about relevant, contemporary poets who speak to our students’ lived experiences. Resources to find compelling poems for students include the Poetry Foundation, Poets.org, and Button Poetry.

Give students five minutes to “write off the poem.” I give students a chance to write about the poem (the author’s main message, etc.), write using the poem (write their own poem based on exemplar sentences I’ve selected), or write about anything else they want. I let students know that I will read their writing and respond to their journals frequently.

Some of my favorite poems to use as models when students need an engagement boost are “Two Names, Two Worlds,” by Jonathan Rodríguez, “My Honest Poem,” by Rudy Francisco, and “For Every One,” by Jason Reynolds. The writing organization 826 Digital also has great resources to help students get their creative writing juices flowing.

Using poetry as a lens to write has increased the engagement of even the most resistant students. As students begin to identify as poets and writers, they build connections with each other through sharing their writing, such as during the Open Mic Fridays I hold, in our student literary magazine, or onstage in our whole-school community meetings.

Strategy 3: Relevancy and Authenticity

When students are lacking engagement, I try to put myself in their shoes. Why would they care? What is making this learning relevant to their lives? They have so much on their plate as young adults. How can I respond to where they are and make the class relevant to them?

I often turn to relevancy. Consider pausing a day of your planned unit to weave in a related contemporary news article or event related to themes of your unit. As my students read The Poet X, by Elizabeth Acevedo, a novel that deals with themes of gender and sexuality, we discussed sexual harassment and assault on school campuses. As a result, students were motivated to raise awareness about sexual harassment in their school. The Article of the Week strategy is a great way to embed current events into your classroom.

More ambitious options include bringing in a guest speaker from the community or hosting a panel of experts to discuss themes from your unit with students. When my students read The 57 Bus, by Dashka Slater, I invited our local state’s attorney and public defenders to discuss themes of juvenile justice. Students’ handwritten thank you notes not only increased engagement, but served as a great check-for-understanding.

When engagement is starting to wane, I also lean on relevancy in terms of authentic assessment and audiences. Recently, my students finished a narrative writing unit. Rather than just share their work with classmates, students shared their writing for fourth graders in our district. Having students present their work to people other than just me helps them take ownership and pride in their work.

Using authentic audiences has also helped increase engagement in some of my book clubs and literacy circles. I asked both students and community members to read a novel over the summer. In September, we discussed the novel together in a “Community Read Book Club” with students, our superintendent, the mayor, city council members, school board members, and city librarians. Placing students in real-life situations naturally increases engagement; learning becomes not about getting a grade, but about performing to your ability because it matters. Assignments like this are not just documents that live in a folder; they are authentic experiences that will stick with students.

There are times throughout the year when even the best teachers see student engagement falter. The trick is what you do when this happens. I always go back to connections: students’ connections to each other, to themselves as writers, and to our community.

Share This Story

  • bluesky icon
  • email icon

Filed Under

  • Student Engagement
  • English Language Arts
  • 6-8 Middle School
  • 9-12 High School

Follow Edutopia

  • facebook icon
  • bluesky icon
  • pinterest icon
  • instagram icon
  • youtube icon
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
George Lucas Educational Foundation
Edutopia is an initiative of the George Lucas Educational Foundation.
Edutopia®, the EDU Logo®, Teacher 2 Teacher Logo®, and Lucas Education Research Logo® are trademarks or registered trademarks of the George Lucas Educational Foundation in the U.S. and other countries.