Instructional Coaching

How Instructional Coaches Can Navigate Difficult Conversations

Step-by-step advice for coaches on how to reconnect and reestablish trust when facing resistance.

November 20, 2026

Your content has been saved!

Go to My Saved Content.
ZeynepKaya / iStock

Every instructional coach knows the feeling.

Midway through a coaching conversation, you notice that your coachee’s body language shifts. The banter dissipates and the energy in the room becomes tense. Engagement in the session more or less ceases. Regardless of the lesson ideas, data, and excitement you brought to your session, the coachee seems to have tapped out.

A coachee’s negative reaction can be surprising and upsetting, leaving you to wonder where you went wrong. If you’ve found yourself in a similar situation—especially if you’re a new instructional coach—you should know that this is a standard part of the process. As classroom teachers, we experienced resistance with our students, and the same sort of resistance can occur with adult learners, too.

The most effective way to address a coachee’s resistance is to establish psychological safety and lead a coaching practice that promotes teacher agency. It’s not helpful, for instance, to dominate conversations about coaching goals. Even still, there are coachees who need more assistance. They may not have a great grasp of what a coach has to offer, or they might have other outstanding concerns.

Below are four steps that allow instructional coaches and coachees to reconnect and reestablish trust during a difficult coaching conversation.

Step One: Accept That Resistance Is an Opportunity to Grow Your Relationship

Here are some common examples of resistance that instructional coaches might encounter:

  • “I don’t feel like I can benefit from having an instructional coach.”
  • “I don’t feel like there’s value in the initiative that we’re working on together.”
  • “I already review my data independently, and don’t understand the purpose of working with a coach.”
  • “How do I know that the work we will do together will remain confidential?”

Early in my career, I believed that resistance reflected poorly on my value and my work as an instructional coach. I now look at resistance as a chance to form a deeper connection with my coachee. The next time a teacher expresses resistance, pause the coaching session and listen carefully to what they have to say. It takes courage for them to express themselves, and you should let them know as much.

Brace for potentially difficult feedback by reframing your viewpoint. You’re not absorbing “complaints”; you’re hearing out an important perspective. You’re on the same team, working toward the same goal.

Step Two: Be Curious, Not Judgmental

Once you provide your coachee with the space to speak freely, it’s vital to maintain a sense of curiosity, not judgment, about why they’re raising certain concerns. Sometimes, coaches who’ve observed a school district’s behind-the-scenes planning for an initiative might be inclined to dismiss concerns, because they feel like the district leadership team is already on top of things. However, I’ve found that by asking more questions and understanding the reasoning behind the resistance, it’s much easier to effectively address possible misunderstandings—or even discover loopholes/errors in the design of an initiative. These are the best questions you can ask your coachee:

  • “What’s the most difficult part about this right now?”
  • “How has having this new task on your plate been impacting you?”
  • “What would have to change about this initiative to make it meaningful for you?”

The goal during this part of the conversation is to put yourself in the coachee’s shoes, while also taking your time digesting responses. Continue to remind yourself that the goal isn’t to work through resistance as quickly as possible. Time and effort are most meaningful to staff.

Step Three: Acknowledge Emotions Before Sharing Solutions

Instructional coaching is inherently emotional work because it requires vulnerability from both participants, but especially the coachee. When a coachee shares what’s on their mind, don’t jump straight into solutions. Instead, emphasize the emotional weight of teaching. Make sure that teachers truly feel validated.

When teachers are overwhelmed, try to reflect their words back at them so they know they’re being heard accurately. This sounds like:

  • “I understand you’re worried about the additional time it will take to input this data in our new system, and how that might impact your work/life balance.”
  • “I understand you’re concerned about changing our reading curriculum to a science of reading approach, and you’re fearful about no longer being able to implement lesson plans you’ve used in the past that have been successful for you and your students.”

These sentence stems are validating: They preempt possible solutions and keep the “human” element in the coaching process.

Step Four: Offer Choices and CoCreate the Path Forward

If the core concern has been expressed and validated, then the coachee is ready to move forward. Rather than mandating a single solution, draw upon your expertise and present a few viable options—then empower teachers to pick their favorite. Solutions should directly address the specific concerns they’ve raised.

  • “What type of assistance would be most helpful to you right now?”
  • “Would you be interested in co-teaching this lesson, so you can see how the new rubric works in practice?”
  • “We could complete this data sheet together, so it takes half the time to input.”
  • “We can work as partners, so I can lift some of the weight off of you as you approach this new unit in our curriculum.”

Trust that your coachee knows what works best for them in their resolution process, then follow their lead as you offer supports.

When instructional coaches embrace the emotional work of coaching sessions, their perspective on navigating difficult conversations evolves for the better. Resistance ceases to come across like something worrisome, negative, or threatening. Above all else, resistance and hesitation are opportunities to support a teacher during the coaching process. You, as an instructional coach, get to help them work through a legitimate boundary, concern, or unmet need. There’s no better part of the job.

Share This Story

  • bluesky icon
  • email icon

Filed Under

  • Instructional Coaching

Follow Edutopia

  • facebook icon
  • bluesky icon
  • pinterest icon
  • instagram icon
  • youtube icon
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
George Lucas Educational Foundation
Edutopia is an initiative of the George Lucas Educational Foundation.
Edutopia®, the EDU Logo®, Teacher 2 Teacher Logo®, and Lucas Education Research Logo® are trademarks or registered trademarks of the George Lucas Educational Foundation in the U.S. and other countries.